WA state politicians eye Utah’s immigrant driver license model

October 29, 2012 by · 2 Comments
Filed under: Uncategorized 
Washington and New Mexico remain the only two states in the country not to  require proof of legal U.S. residency when applying for a driver’s license.

But the races for governor and attorney general have brought renewed  attention to a proposal that would create a two-tiered driver’s license system  in Washington to address the issue of driving by immigrants who can’t provide  proof of legal U.S. residency.

Under the proposal known as the Utah model, a person who can’t prove U.S.  residency can get a permit that allows them to drive, but that document is not a  valid identification.

Republican gubernatorial candidate Rob McKenna backs the idea, and attorney  general candidates Republican Reagan Dunn and Democrat Bob Ferguson speak of it  favorably.

“The idea that you should be able to obtain (a key identity document) without  proving you’re a legal resident of the country is seriously mistaken,” McKenna  said during a debate in Yakima earlier this month.

McKenna’s opponent, Democrat Jay Inslee, has said he prefers keeping  Washington’s current system in place.

Over the years, this has been a contentious issue in Olympia that pits  immigrant advocacy groups against conservatives.

Immigrant groups argue that when undocumented immigrants have access to  driver’s licenses, it creates safer roads and allows them to purchase insurance.  Opponents say that failing to ask for proof of U.S. residency invites identity  fraud and could end up putting noncitizens in the state’s voter rolls.

In Utah, one industry that relies heavily on immigrant labor hasn’t seen much  change since the law there was passed in 2005.

“Certainly there are labor shortages in our agricultural community, but we  didn’t feel (the driver’s license law) had a significant impact,” said Sterling  Brown, vice president of public policy at the Utah Farm Bureau Federation. “It  has not had an immediate or significant impact on the agriculture  community.”

According to Utah Driver License Division data, the number of people applying  for the Driving Privilege Card has steadily climbed since 2005, from 21,600 to  38,997 in 2011. It peaked at 43,000 in 2008. That same year a state audit found  that more than 75 percent of people who had the driving permit also had active  car insurance, comparable to the 82 percent rate of drivers with a regular  license.

But now immigrant rights groups in Utah are worried about information sharing  between the state and the federal government.

In the 2011 legislative session, lawmakers changed the law to mandate the  state to notify U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement if an applicant has a  felony on this record. If the individual applying has a misdemeanor warrant  outstanding, the state notifies the agency who sought the person’s arrest.

Luis Garza, executive director of Comunidades Unidas, says he’s concerned  that people with minor offenses such as traffic infractions will be caught in  the dragnet. He’s also worried about the database of people applying for the  driving permits being leaked.

Beyond that, the system creates a two-class society, he said.

“They have big red letters saying for `driving privilege only’,” Garza said.  “Anyone who shows that card — who may or may not be undocumented in the country  — is a second class citizen.”

In 2010, the Utah Legislature created another driving permit for noncitizen  legal residents, who initially could get the Driving Privilege Card. Still,  nearly 160 legal immigrants have the permit.

It’s not just immigrant rights groups who oppose the two-tier system. In  2011, a Republican state senator wanted to undue the law because he saw the  driving permit as a magnet for undocumented immigrants

In Washington, numerous bills to require proof of U.S. residency have been  filed but have never made it the floor of any legislative chamber in recent  memory. A bill using the Utah model was introduced in 2011, but did not make it  out of committee.

In 2010, the Department of Licensing answered some of the concerns about  driver’s licenses by narrowing the documents that it now requires to provide  proof of Washington residency. It now requires proof of a valid Washington  residence address if an applicant doesn’t provide a verified Social Security  number. The proof documents, such as rental agreements, will be copied and  verified by the agency before a permanent license is issued.

“First and foremost, we believe the current system works and we want as much  as possible that DOL doesn’t become ICE,” said Toby Guiven, public policy  director at OneAmerica, an immigrant advocacy group.

According to Department of Licensing data, fewer out-of-state people who  didn’t provide a Social Security number have sought to obtain a driver’s license  in Washington in the last two years, suggesting the department’s new  restrictions are deterring undocumented immigrants from other state from getting  a license here.

The department’s data shows that in 2011, 9,237 people didn’t provide a  Social Security number when obtaining a license. In all of 2010, more than  23,000 did not. As of October of 2012, more than 5,000 have.

Guiven argued that creating a new system would add costs to the state budget,  new bureaucracies and more wait time at the local DMV office.

In Utah, wait lines did increase shortly after the new law was passed, but  subsequently decreased, according to an audit.

One unsolved issue around driver’s licenses is the arrival of the federal  REAL ID act. It was passed in 2005, but its implementation has been delayed  since then. The latest deadline for states to come into compliance is January of  next year. But officials expect that deadline to be extended.

Department of Licensing spokeswoman Chris Anthony said the Department of  Homeland Security has asked for so far an update package for the state at the  end of October, but that’s it so far.

She added that state lawmakers passed a measure that prohibited the  department from acting on REAL ID until the federal government provided  money.

Reporting by the Associated Press.

Read more: http://latino.foxnews.com/latino/politics/2012/10/29/wa-politicians-eye-utah-immigrant-license-system-as-model/#ixzz2Aj34JUxJ


2 Responses to “WA state politicians eye Utah’s immigrant driver license model”
  1. BeatTheChip says:

    I really want to help fight Real ID in Washington State, but I don’t know enough about locals and what they want.

  2. Lois says:

    What would you like to know about ‘locals’? We at Stop The Checkpoints do want to keep drivers’ licenses available to all including undocumented immigrants. We are also against the increasing surveillance and militarization of our community, but have not specifically discussed the REAL ID.

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!